Jason and Tiffany Mertlich have two girls and boy, and are pregnant with a fourth kid. To reveal the gender of the new baby to their children, they made a surprised colored cake, blue for a boy and pink for a girl.

The moment the oldest boy Gunner cuts the cake and realizes it’s pink he can’t help but break down.

“It’s a girl! It’s a girl? Oh no!” he cried

Dad couldn’t help but respond honestly, “You had the same reaction I did bud.”

“I don’t want the girl cake. I don’t like girls!” Gunner wailed.

On the bright side, the two little sisters couldn’t seem happier!